Monday, August 30, 1999 Online Edition 172 |
Sex, religion and dancing
By NIGEL POTTER Most churches disapprove of dancing, even if they don't actually forbid it. They see it as licentious and immoral. Not so most indigenous religions, where dance plays an integral part in most spiritual ceremonies and celebrations. That is not to say that indigenous dancing cannot be licentious, it's that indigenous cultures are not as obsessed with the divisions that non-indigenous cultures tend to be: work/leisure, school/play, body/spirit, the sacred/the profane, everyday life/religious life. In the indigenous world these definitions hardly exist. They are not even different sides of the same coin but more or less integrated into one harmonious whole. Of course, indigenous dances are not necessarily erotic either. One only has to think of the Lenca group of dancers: "Los Negritos" based in Santa Elena, La Paz with their endless shuffle as they dance in a circle or lead a procession through the town. But they are always exciting, with their brightly colored and heavily decorated wooden masks, rattle in one hand, horse tail in the other held behind their buttocks. They let out small cries, whoops and hollers as they occasionally break ranks to chase some terrified yet delighted child back into the crowd. The feria days that celebrate their saint (James, Santiago) or the town's patron saint or the maize festival would be unthinkable without the Negritos, and would certainly be a lot poorer without them. Yet from time to time church authorities have tried to suppress them or put them down as godless, pagan, indian rites. DANCING AT THE CRUCIFIXION Such a shame really when the indigenous themselves have no problem at all with certain aspects of Christianity, the crucifixion for instance. The Plains Indians of North America can get into that and go one better. They offer themselves up in a Christ-like sacrifice for their people to redeem the Native American world. And they dance while they do it. It's hard to imagine dancing during a crucifixion but they manage it. Tied to a tree by long thongs attached to their bodies by skewers piercing their chest or back, they dance for hours until they pull away and the flesh holding the skewers gives and they drop bleeding to the ground. This true sun dance is a very holy time but also a very sociable one with much feasting. Our dancing in the non-indigenous world is kept at arm's length from the religious. Except for some African churches or churches in the deep south of the United States, never shall the twain meet. For us religion is serious, our souls are at stake, so it is also joyless and lifeless. We may feel "uplifted" or "holy" (holier than thou) but it is a grim feeling, no one is having a good time. If we want a "good time," we rather guiltily have to sneak away from the church to cross to the other side of the tracks to the night-club, the discotheque, the theater. Dancing has been defined as doing perpendicularly what you would rather be doing horizontally and when you go to a night-club you get the point. But you don't join in, just gawk: a young woman gyrates up and down a pole, maybe whips off her knickers, a flash of bush and she is gone. It is neither sacred nor profane, just obscene in that it is basically boring and insulting to both the stripper and to the ripped-off. Much more erotic are dances where no one takes their clothes off. Witness the Argentinean Zamba where a very fully-clothed couple circle round each other, passing scarves or handkerchiefs over one another, never once touching. It is so beautiful, the ecstasy is almost spiritual but the physical isn't far behind. CELEBRATING SEX And what about our own Honduran folkloric dancing? Watching skillful adult dancers for instance in Tegucigalpa's Central Park is an exciting experience in every sense of the word: it is a playful and joyful and I always feel happier and pleased to be alive after seeing them but there's never any doubt what these energetic and youthful dancers are after. And I celebrate that. Isn't that, after all, what most of us, are after? Sex is, or should be, joyful and carefree and a part of all our lives. The best/worst kept universal secret that brought us all and our children into this life. Still, if sleazy night-clubs or raucous dancing isn't up your street, you can always go up-market and watch a ballet. But it is much the same thing only more "respectable," though sometimes I am at a loss to understand how or why. Certainly the music is usually "classical," the lighting wonderful and the movements so graceful and beautiful as to be spiritually uplifting. But it's soaked in sex too: the men in those tights, all bumps, buttocks and balls, and the women in the miniest of mini-skirts, throwing themselves around (or being thrown around) every five minutes spreading their legs wide revealing to all the holy-of-holies covered by a little strip of white satin. Naughtily but nice and ever-so-arty. How can anyone think ballet is prim and proper? The same goes for ballroom dancing. When I was a boy my mother insisted on my having lessons. Full of teenage rebellion, I revolted against such boring bourgeois customs. What a chance missed. At least you get to hold the girl, talk to each other or dance cheek-to-cheek as you prefer. Have you ever seen a tango well danced? But the best dancing, like most indigenous dances, is communal. Many times I have danced Scottish reels in fields, barns or houses. You have your own partner but you dance with everybody else's. The sex is there of course, but so is the joy. You jig, skip, spin and whirl, the sweat pours off you, you feel good. Resentments, irritations, worries, disappointments and depressions melt away. SPIRITUAL VITALITY LACKING I once danced with a million other people in the streets of Washington D.C. Surrounded by heavily armed troops and police, it was a spiritually ecstatic experience. I never felt more at peace or closer to my fellow human beings. Recently I danced in the Parque Central of Siguatepeque with my two-year-old daughter to several marimba bands. Everyone was doing it: the good, bad and the ugly; the old and the young; the skillful and the incompetent shufflers. Nobody gave a damn. For a moment we could forget the problems that beset Honduras and beleaguered our own lives. As we danced in the night air we were celebrating; we were giving thanks, it felt good to be alive. And isn't that what religion is supposed to be about? Trouble is I don't find this spiritual vitality in conventional religion but I see at all the time in indigenous cultures. Those shuffling dancing Indians little know how they inspired this white, middle-class Englishman. I dance the whole time at home. When I am down and blue, I dance my troubles away. When I am happy I dance to celebrate my job and give thanks. Sadly it's a private hole-in-the-corner affair: people think I am weird. It definitely doesn't attract women, rather it frightens them off. Still, my children are young and open enough to enjoy it, so we all dance together. I never danced with my parents which I think was a shame. I danced when my father died though. Just as the churches have decried indigenous ceremonies as blasphemous, lacking in spiritual devotion, no doubt many would condemn my behavior as outrageous, lacking in all respect for my poor dead father, not to mention my mother lying in the next room in the throes of Alzheimers. Still, that is the way it was. Feeling as if I were the saddest most lonesome son in the world, I poured myself a large whisky,laughed and wept through a Marx Brothers' movie on the T.V. then put on some music and danced. My brother suddenly arrived and caught me in the act. He joined in and so there were two grown men leaping around the room like dervishes. It gave us the comfort and courage to face the days ahead, bury our dad and sort out our mad, old mother. I hope when I die people will dance on my grave. If they want to whisper a prayer for my spirit too that's fine by me. But I hope they will eat and drink and be merry-sad. There's nothing like another's death to make one feel really alive and glad to be so. Yes, the time will come for each and everyone of us but, Phew! Praise to the Lord, not this time, so be good Indians and dance on! Nigel Potter is an Englishman who has lived for a number of years in the highlands of Western Honduras. |
Muchos machos, pocos hombres On several occasions, articles have been printed in the Spanish daily La Tribuna about the high birth rate in Honduras and its incongruence with the nation's future. The average number of children per family is four and there are many cases of families with 10 or more. To this, we have to add the "irresponsible paternity" rate that reaches the sky-high mark of 70 percent, which means that seven out of 10 children do not know what a father is. Then, statistics show that when a child goes to school, 70 percent of the teachers are female. At the university (where only 1 percent of high school graduates assist), the average is 65 percent female teachers. When will a Honduran child learn from male role models when there are so few men at school and fewer at home? Much is said about Latin machismo but is it not in part perpetuated by women? When asked about family planning and why she had so many children, a single mother replied that the children helped her at home and with the errands. Many have tried to confront this social phenomenon where religious beliefs and confusion substitute the real sense of family. Modern theory contends that an executive employee should have no more than seven people under his or her charge so that the chain of communication is strong. So how can an uneducated mother or father give his or her weak orientation to a large number of children? The clergy continues to preach that family planning is un-Christian. Can those who preach this not see that it is also un-Christian to have a huge family oriented toward begging, suffering and crime? It is the state's obligation to watch over the Honduran family and the hospital infrastructure where there should be more education for families regarding the optimum number of children, which is two. They should be taught that life in the family depends on quality, not quantity. At the Vatican, where population growth is zero, the theory that produces the practice of large families may be applicable. But here, where the problem is out of control, it is not recommended. We want the best for our country, and the best is family planning. For this next millennium, the concept of family must be restored. Crime has taken a dangerous leap in our society. Returning to the family would be a good remedy for all our problems.
|
THE EMPEROR WEARS NO CLOTHES! Dear Editor: The indignation expressed by Elizabeth Nutter Valladares and Howard Rosenzweig, et al (in your Aug. 14 edition) is reminiscent of the protests of the emperor and his legion. Both clearly demonstrate greater concern for their own financial interests than for the safety of foreign visitors. All parties would be better served by seeking solutions, rather than fervently denying the obvious. Jesse W. Jamison Dear Editor: [I wish to add] further to the discussion on the horrendous crime rate here in Honduras and Mr. Gutman's excellent observations on how things really are in this poor country. The rebuttal by Mr. Rosenzweig and 53 residents of Copan Ruinas is obviously self-serving and unrealistic. I'm sure that Copan does not have the problems we have here in the big cities yet, and just as obviously Mr. Rosenzweig et al have not been the victims of any crimes or suffered the incompetence (which we all hope is only temporary while they reorganize) of police. I can assure all of them that when these chickens do come home to roost in their neighborhoods they will think again about taking such ostrich-like attitudes. Practical anarchy reigns in many areas of Honduras, police protection at this time being nonexistent (try calling 991 here). Murder rates are higher than in most major U.S. cities including New York, and rape, robbery, kidnapping, etc. are all out of control. Never a day goes by in San Pedro Sula when somebody you know does not suffer from a major crime. The U.S. State Department is concerned for the safety of its citizens in Honduras. Get your head out of the sand, Mr. Rosenzweig, this is no time to play the "sweep it under the carpet game." We all need to add our outrage to prevalent conditions. Waving pieces of paper with "peace in our time" written on them will only lead as it did before to worse violence and deteriorating conditions. Thank you, Mr. Gutman, for telling it like it really is. I found it ironic that the letter written by the poor tourists whose son was robbed and beaten in Tela appeared immediately after Mr. Rosenzweig's silly letter. And in that lies the reality of conditions. Roy Stratford CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY Dear Editor: The article by W. E. Gutman on why tourists stay away from our country will take away food from the mouths of all hard-working Hondurans for years to come. Mr. Gutman professes to be a social activist concerned with problems such as poverty, yet he has done irreversible damage to the best option Hondurans have for decent employment and wages. Rising crime and violence is occurring at all tourist destinations including the United States. Although we should all be concerned about these issues, unbalanced negative articles also contribute to reduce the benefits we urgently need from tourism. The state of Colorado has one of the most vibrant ecotourism industries in the world yet crime is a fact of life and pollution is rampant in many areas due to toxic waste, uranium tailings and the famous Denver "Brown Cloud" from automobile emissions. Having done my master's thesis on migrant farm workers and Native Americans in Colorado, I can assure you that human rights' violations are committed daily while the level of poverty of these two groups is similar to Third World levels. The Littleton School massacre was much worse than any shoot-out in Honduras. Nevertheless, the solution to Colorado's problems is not to viciously attack its tourism industry so that tourists will stay away and hundreds of thousands of people will lose their jobs, be unable to pay their mortgages and end up hungry and destitute. We were hit with one of the most devastating hurricanes in history and we need foreign investment to get back on our feet. The dirt that Mr. Gutman throws upon our people destroys our future well-being. As the president of a non-profit environmental organization that manages a wildlife refuge (Fundacion Cuero y Salado) and generates half of its funds from tourist visits, I can assure you that Mr. Gutman's article has done incredible damage to the conservation movement in Honduras. His article will reduce our ability to have the resources to protect our national parks and watersheds. He says that visitors are scarce and a vigorous and thriving industry is but a distant dream, but the statistics indicate the opposite. In 1996 we had 263,000 tourists while in 1998 we had 321,000. In 1996, tourism generated $115 million while in 1999 it went up to almost $170 million. Tourism is the biggest industry in the world and Honduras has one of the biggest potentials in eco-tourism which would generate employment and the hard currency necessary to buy our fuel, medicines and other vital imports. We are one of the most spectacular countries in the world with the most beautiful mountains, rivers, and waterfalls of Central America. I founded the first whitewater rafting company in Honduras and now there are many more proving to the world that we are a world-class rafting and kayaking destination. How can someone who comes from a country where black churches, schools, day care centers and synagogues are attacked with gunfire and burnt down accuse Honduras of having a monopoly on crime and violence? To attack the best chance we have to improve the socio-economic situation of our people in such an unbalanced manner constitutes a crime against the humanity of all Hondurans. Pepe Herrero |
Monday, August 23, 1999 Online Edition 171 |
One of many tourism destinations There are many voices in the tourism sector crying out for effective promotion outside our country to create more investment and development. To this effect, some of these voices have called on media like us to be accomplices in communicating only the benevolent aspects of our country. They want us to show only the good parts and to edit out the not-so-nice. The point is that tourism is just part of the big picture we show in HTW. We have never been a "tourism" weekly. We are a generic information medium in much demand with 200,000 hits on our website to prove it. The Ministerio de Turismo, the government's office in charge of managing all aspects of tourism, invested what is estimated to be $1.8 million this year promoting Honduras. Some members of the industry have reported to us that the promotion has worked and in fact there has been a rising demand for their services. A sector has shown no results and others, have reported that people have made their reservations for Honduras but, that after reading our pages, have canceled. That is how good we are. Our concept of being a communication medium does not consist of promoting Honduras with lies or farce. Our goal is to be objective with the purpose of informing, which translates into advising. If we say that walking in such and such a place after twelve at night, or twelve in the day for that matter, is dangerous, it is because we want people to know. We do not want to cry later over spilt milk or anything else that can be spilled. Everyone has a job to do. There are those here who are dedicated to informing about the weekly robberies and other phenomena. Ours, in part, is to report to nationals and foreigners alike, the real Honduras because not every little thing she does is magic. If we were alarmists, and we do not feel we are, we have the good sense and presence of mind to tell it like it is. For example, when Mitch hit in force and President Flores had sent an S.O.S. to the world, HTW had already done so and had informed about our situation 36 hours before, in a way that we believe, was not far off the mark. We have advised about many things and waited for others to do their jobs. We have insisted that tourism authorities and other Ministerios translate the denunciations we have received and published, and then send them to the pertinent authorities so they take corrective measures. But there is no follow-up to our work. In an African country with much tourism, five tourists were killed. The authorities are still looking for a way to fix the past and bring back the tourists they had before. That is not the way to do things, but it seems there are similarities here and we simply do not want that. On several occasions we have sent communiques to the Ministerio de Turismo about complaints from our readers we have received directly in HTW about tourism and other authorities, but we are still waiting for answers and action. Tourism in Honduras is disoriented and needy of an urgent revision in its structure with other entities. Sometimes it appears it is going nowhere. We do not want tourists just for today, we want tourists forever.
Gringo meets Hondurena:
By ERLING DUUS CHRISTENSEN Soon, a new crop of Gringo males will be descending on Honduras. They will be school-teachers, Peace Corps volunteers, employees of various agencies and organizations, or just wanderers in search of adventure. They will be of all ages, dispositions, and shapes. Most of them will have as a main interest or preoccupation the famous Honduran woman. And, for the most part, Honduran women will be interested in them. This can be a good thing, or be a prelude to a distressing comedy of errors. In some cases the meeting between the Hondurena and the Gringo will result in marriage. Whether or not that is a good thing, is not easily determined, or generalized about. On the other hand, many Gringos will leave the country after a time having had a good experience and vowing to return. Others, however, will plummet from one disaster to another, and will finally leave, bruised and battered, or in some cases, stay, bruised and embittered. I do not wish to claim any particular expertise in this subject. Any man who would claim expertise about any group of women whatsoever is a fool going in, but I have been around awhile, have had some experience and, most importantly, have witnessed the adventures and misadventures of many Gringos in this country. Honduran women of all ages have charm and often beauty. A man with his eyes open can hardly fail to notice that. They have a wonderful femininity. They enjoy being women. It is very rare to see women who are interested in being like men, dressing like men, talking like men, working like men, or thinking like men. Very few Honduran women grow up envying men, and modeling themselves after them. They recognize that men have some very clear advantages in the society which they may well resent, but they nevertheless tend to look benevolently down on man as an inferior species, and carry an obvious pride of gender. The man, like the rooster, is "cock-sure," which makes for much colorful strutting around the barnyard, but seems a bit ridiculous all the same compared to the quiet confidence of the woman who is "hen-sure." She, after all, knows who lays the eggs. As a result of her pleasure and confidence in being a woman, the Honduran woman loves to flirt-young, old, poor or rich, married or unmarried, the Honduran lady flirts as naturally as a flower blooms. She does this without self-consciousness. Much of the zest and sparkle of life here derives from this. It is playful, and for the most part innocent. It usually does not mean -- and most Gringos never learn this -- that she can hardly wait to jump in bed with them. It is great for the male ego, of course, but needs to be held in a certain perspective that can be hard to achieve. The ladies of Honduras have a positive loathing of men who come on in a crude or brutal manner, or who are suggestive in an insensitive and dehumanizing manner. They despise cold-eyed and lust-filled stares. But they are very responsive to friendly smiles, humor, and playfulness. Any modestly attractive man of whatever age and shape who moves about the city in an aura of warmth and liveliness can quickly make numerous lady friends every day. What has been said thus far is true of the Honduran woman in all social classes. But in other important ways, class differences are critical. I knew a Gringo whose idea of a date was to plop the lady on the back of his motorcycle and haul her up to his apartment for an afternoon or an evening. But he always found something wrong with the ladies upon whom he bestowed this privilege. He found them boring, shallow, manipulative, or pathetic. "But Ralph" (not his real name), I would point out, "no quality woman in Honduras is going to go to your apartment on a first date." Who he was having success with were the tramps, the neurotics, and the desperate. These can be found in all social classes, of course, but it is generally girls whose lives are consumed by the clutches of poverty and who are desperate for a way out, who easily fall in line with the amorous schemes of men. There are women from the middle and upper classes, to be sure, who are "easy," but they nevertheless require a degree of careful courtship. The fact of the matter is that most nice, intelligent, and serious Honduran women are very conservative. They come on dates with chaperons, and dread the thought of causing scandal or shame to their families. Only a small number rebel seriously against the traditional mores of the society. Tegucigalpa is a small city, Honduras a small country, and it provides little anonymity. Someone you know will always see you wherever you go, and if you get a bad reputation, you will keep it all your life. You will be pursued only by the numberless lists of gentlemen not looking for a wife, the would-be Lotharios eager to add another notch to their guns. Honduran women are often sweet and yielding. But I have known very few who are weak and passive. If they submit to male domination, they do it for love and as part of a strategy. They have normally been treated like little queens in childhood, and they do not usually have the kind of low self-esteem that afflicts so many young women in the United States. Eating disorders like anorexia are nearly unknown here. Women have vivid and strong personalities, are often stubborn, determined, and used to being very responsible. They traditionally have to endure many hardships, but there is a place within where you are likely to find steel and not putty. They know who they are, at some instinctive level. Men who are committed to manipulating and shaping them according to their amorous desire are going to have a hard time of it in the long run. The assertion that women in Honduras know who they are must be balanced against another reality, which is that women here are allowed very little time or space for self-realization. Introspection is not generally valued, and individualism is suspect. Many ladies are very adventuresome, and aspire to high and intoxicating flight, but the society begins early with its industrious clipping of their wings. It is assumed that women should be more or less controlled, and that they will want to marry at a young age, have three to five children, and find their highest calling and fulfillment as loyal self-sacrificing wives and mothers. A women who doubts any of that is regarded with suspicion. One thing above all must be understood. Honduran life is a survival of the fittest, and women are its most vulnerable segment, especially poor women, which is to say something like 80 percent. The family is their only bastion of support and protection, and in many cases that does not amount to much. So they become what they must be, tough, wary survivors. That is not incompatible with sweetness and charm, though it can be in tension with it. It is the way that things are, and lacking much change, will be. But many a Gringo has become a victim from not knowing or understanding. Too many of them think that they, along with Alice, have stumbled into Wonderland. |
Author stands by
perspective piece on violence in Honduras
By W. E. GUTMAN Understandably, many readers, especially those protective of their commercial interests, were upset with the data presented in my recent article on Copan; the conjectures these facts elicit left some positively livid. The data are just that. Culled from various State Department documents, they can be independently verified through the Internet or obtained at the U.S. Embassy and consular offices. Based on careful observations of daily life, police reports and other sources, these warnings are intended to inform and counsel. Conscious of escalating crime and violence, the Honduran government has been careful not to contradict these admonitions. The inferences that pepper the article -- and for which I offer no apology -- are a distillate of intimate experience, anecdotal field notes and intelligence from trusted sources that, in my absence, act as my eyes and ears. Pointing fingers at recent violence in the United States (Columbine High School, etc.) is sheer obfuscation, a reflex designed to deflect from the incident in Copan, or to find in it some desperate rationalization. The shootings in the United States are aberrant acts by tormented individuals, some of whom had the wisdom to surrender, others the civility to take their own lives. The thugs who sprayed the small pulperia with assault rifles are incapable of such gallantry. Dramatically down (unlike Honduras) crime in the United States invites instantaneous and massive police response, and becomes the focus of intense and persistent media scrutiny. Characteristically, the Copan police ran the other way and the incident was either ignored or given suspiciously marginal coverage. These realities should raise a red flag about the integrity of Honduras' criminal justice system and warn stridently of the pusillanimity of its media. In both journalism and "show-biz" one is only as good as one's last offering. Whereas a bad script or a weak performance is eventually forgotten, a journalist earns acclaim -- or calumny -- less for his adherence to form than his devotion to substance. So long as he steers clear from the truth, or "sanitizes" it, he has nothing to fear, not the ire of some readers, nor the respect of others. Fickle and self-serving, the public entombs what it need not remember and enshrines what it will doggedly not forget. Anyone familiar with my work knows that succor, praise and compassion have steadfastly tempered my occasional polemics. I've applauded, rhapsodized, commiserated with, and wept for, Honduras. I've elegized Copan in words and photos. Mr. Rosenzweig's establishment, La Casa De Cafe, where I stayed on three separate occasions, was the subject of a fittingly flattering write-up in HTW and other publications. I gave other establishments similar accolades, in writing and by word of mouth, locally and abroad. Mr. Rosenzweig and his co-signatories clearly suffer from selective amnesia, a pardonable offense under the circumstances. Designed to discredit and silence me, their scurrilous attack on my motives and professional integrity, is not. Their lack of objectivity reflects a region-wide aversion for investigative journalism. They are unwittingly playing straight into the hands of those who would gag a free press. The incident in Copan, I repeat and affirm, is symptomatic of the turmoil gripping Honduras. The very fact that it took place in normally "laid back" Copan should be all the more alarming and inadmissible. The timidity of my detractors in the face of incontrovertible facts may be precisely what is wrong with Copan and, by extension, with Honduras as a whole. Notwithstanding the half-truths, innuendos and outright fabrications dished out in their truculent epistle, I stand by my article, by my sources and by my instincts. An upcoming perspective will offer further elaboration.
|
Monday, August 16, 1999 Online Edition 170 |
Keep it heterogeneous The students that graduate from these schools and go on to the National University, according to some teachers, achieve excellent grades. Their educational base is up to the university's standards. Also, many of the graduates go to other countries where they finish studying within normal time-frames and academic expectations. Around 5,000 teachers, among which about a third are foreign, tend to these schools. All of those we know are very capable. We can be proud because each year many Hondurans are adequately prepared for a future where English is the language of business and diplomacy. In the short term, our country will have executives who dominate Shakespeare's language, in all enterprises, contributing so to the good of our nation. All this is good. Now, we have to apply a different mentality to our remote communities like the Garifuna, Chorti and others, which little by little are being invaded by the language of "ladinos," that is, Spanish. Our Constitution orders the protection of national ethnic communities. The respect for their idiosyncracies must be integral in such a way that authorities and teachers must be trained exclusively so they have an understanding of their own particular ways and languages. For example, a policeman sent to work in the Bay Islands should be from there or should know the language. This goes also for every other government official sent to all areas of our nation, so that the particular cultures and traditions are respected and so conserved, as is expressed in our constitution. We must understand that not all of our society should be invaded with external cultures and languages. Some are better left untouched. Maybe we should even learn from them instead of trying to teach them the hard way. Violence obstacle to triumph of democracy By ERLING DUUS CHRISTENSEN Motoring through Guatemala very recently created a degree of apprehension due to the frequency of highway banditry that country has suffered since its brutal civil war. What a pleasant surprise, then, to discover that a highway patrol has recently been established in that country, and everywhere, even in rather lonely locations, one finds the members of this force in new vehicles patrolling the highways. Furthermore, the officers are polite and helpful, well-spoken and at least modestly educated, not in the least the suspicious and threatening thugs one might have anticipated. To add to the positive impression, the roadways are being well-kept, and little garbage is to be seen strewn about the road-side. The contrast with Honduras could not be greater. If Guatemala can do this, why not Honduras? What is required is little more than that the people with wealth and power in the society care enough to invest publicly in their society, contributing significant portions of their political and economic capital to the common welfare rather than building private mansions and economic empires. Honduras has not had a big problem with highway banditry, though that is rapidly changing, and it needs to move quickly to emulate the Guatemala example before the situation deteriorates further. Meanwhile, we read of the creation of a special force of 20 well trained, well-armed, and presumably well-paid law enforcement professionals under the direction of the minister of security. Excellent. They need to be followed by 20 more. Such a force could quickly break the back of criminal gangs, drug cartels, and government corruption, providing of course they are independent of politics and enjoy the full support of the judiciary. The increasing reign of criminal violence in Honduran society represents a very great obstacle to the triumph of democracy. Up until now, there have been few indications that Hondurans have the will to effectively combat criminality. The truth is, no doubt, that the ruling class has not wanted a law enforcement agency with the power and independence to monitor or arrest them, and now they along with the rest of society are starting to pay the inevitable price. This must change. Good luck to Security Minister Elizabeth Cruz Sierra and the new agents. They will need it, but with the right support they can make a difference.
FELICIDADES HONDURAS! Dear Editor: I would like to congratulate Honduras for their Silver Medal win in soccer at the Pan Am Games here in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. Even though I did not have the opportunity to watch the soccer final between Mexico vs. Honduras for the Gold Medal, I was cheering for your team. I did have the opportunity to see some of the events and be part of the Pan Am spirit that felt very alive in this city of Winnipeg. It was nice to see so many people from all over the Americas come together for this special event. I came to Tegucigalpa this past March to help build a home for a mother and her three children. I enjoyed the culture, language and the love of the people [so much] that I hope to return someday again. I had the chance to experience the excitement of your country's game -- soccer. I was in Tegucigalpa's newest mall in the food court, when the crowd erupted with cheers, whistles and hugs. I was not aware what was going on at that moment, but my interpreter told me that the Honduras had just scored a goal. Then she gave me advanced warning of the replay. Again the crowd cheered loudly. I had never seen that much enthusiasm for a sporting event in my life. May your soccer team wear their medals with honor because they worked hard for their win. I am sure the team has brought the spirit of Winnipeg, Canada to Honduras. Brian Van de Ban PEOPLE IN GLASS HOUSES... Dear Editor: How embarrassing for your newspaper that you chose to publish unsubstantiated material in the recent article on Copan Ruinas. You did not mention that the reporter does not live nor has he visited here in over a year, so how could he possibly know what the situation was that night or is at the moment, much less the feeling of the community afterwards or now. Atlanta, Colorado, Alabama, etc., he has a lot of nerve talking about one isolated incident in Honduras. People in glass houses should not throw stones. Elizabeth Nutter Valladares
Dear Editor: The perspective piece by W.E. Gutman titled, Why tourists stay away. Rising crime and violence, that's why [HTW, July 31] did a great disservice to not only the community of Copán Ruinas but the entire tourism sector nationwide. The article was one-sided, biased and completely lacking in objectivity. To make a blanket assertion that potential international visitors would be better off postponing a visit to Honduras at this time due to a precarious security situation is nothing less than an outright distortion and speaks for the lack of objectivity and professionalism of the author as well as the editor for running such a piece. First off the article gives the impression that the village of Copán Ruinas has become a town "habituated to intermittent violence and accustomed to looking the other way." We the undersigned take exception to this assertion. By no means has Copán Ruinas taken on the aforementioned characteristics asserted in the article. We would venture to say that Copán Ruinas is one of the safest, most tranquil, laid back towns in all of Honduras and perhaps Central America as well. Over 100,000 tourists visit Copán Ruinas during an average year and crimes against tourists have been virtually nonexistent over the years. How many tourist towns in Central America can make this assertion? Not many I assure you. Of course, Copán is not an island and the problems around us do find their way here. There have been a few murders, a stolen car or two, a couple of robberies, which are to be expected. Obviously, the recent shooting in which five innocent bystanders were killed, including one tourist, was horrible and received the blanket condemnation by the entire town. But this incident was by no means indicative of a growing wave of violence and crime in Copán Ruinas. It was simply a terrible, isolated incident. The author seems to treat the village of Copán as in some way a "silent participant" in the shooting of the five persons. The good people of Copán Ruins did not shut its "collective mouth" nor wince in a "terror driven reflex." We the undersigned are not even sure how the author was able to get such detailed information on the pulse of the communities opinion on the shooting, given the fact that we know for a fact that the author was not in Copán Ruinas after the shooting in question to interview residents. The article also takes aim at the local police, which we do admit leave much to be desired in terms of efficiency and crime fighting abilities. However, the article makes the unsubstantiated assertion that the local police were in some way involved or covered up the shooting incident. Where the author got this information from confounds us. There has been absolutely no talk in town regarding the possible involvement of the police in the shooting or any talk of an attempt by the police to cover up the matter. This assertion is patently false. The author also takes potshots at the national press in their coverage of the shooting incident. He stated La Prensa "buried" the story on page 75, which is actually untrue because La Prensa ran a front page photo and caption. The author quotes the La Tribuna and El Heraldo newspapers as "declining comment" on the case, giving the false impression that for some strange reason the national press engaged in some macabre conspiracy to keep the incident quiet and out of the public spotlight, which is totally a false assumption by the author. The author then uses the shooting incident and other senseless crimes of late to generalize and hypothesize that this is the reason which explains "why visitors are scarce and a vigorous and thriving tourist industry is but a distant dream." There are numerous reasons that have absolutely nothing to do with crime that explain why Honduras is not attracting its accustomed share of tourists this year. Top on the list is the lingering effects of Hurricane Mitch which struck last October. Other reasons that explain why a thriving tourism industry is but a distant dream are lack of marketing and promotion by the Honduran Institute of Tourism and a lack of marketing and promotion by the private tourism sector in Honduras. And lastly a lack of clear government policy to promote tourism as a national priority. Mr. Gutman makes liberal use of U.S. State Department advisory warnings regarding the current security situation in Honduras. Again we reiterate that such advisories, like Mr. Gutman's musings, are overly alarmist and exaggerate greatly the situation. Towards the end of the article, Mr. Gutman quotes a retired CIA analyst as stating that, "the current unrest (in Honduras) is liable to bring the country to the brink of civil disorder." For those of us who call Honduras home, this statement reeks of a total lack of knowledge of Honduran history both past and present. There is absolutely no talk within Honduras today as to the even slightest, most remote possibility that the current security situation could lead to a period of civil disorder. This is a complete fabrication and a grave distortion of the facts and further shows an utter lack of understanding about Honduras' political, social, cultural and historical context. Journalism such as the article in question does little to help to foment tourism in Honduras. In fact, its purpose is to deter tourists from embarking on vacation trips to Honduras. And in the end who will feel the effects and suffer? Not the foreign journalist who makes a twice yearly fact-finding trip from the United States to Honduras. It is the people of Honduras who will bear the lion's share of the burden caused by a downturn in tourism. Honduras This Week has done a great disservice to the people of Honduras by printing such articles whose only intention is to sow the seeds of gloom and doom. As we stumble towards the door of the new millennium it will take the efforts of many to make Honduras a more liveable and just society. Just perhaps, tourism can play a positive role in this endeavor, God willing. Howard Rosenzweig and 53 residentsCopán Ruinas MORE ON CRIME AND TOURISM Dear Editor: My wife, two sons and I came to Honduras for the first time to visit a friend in Tela. Our friend picked us up in the airport near San Pedro Sula, accompanied by two uniformed police as protection against hijacking that was commonly taking place on the highway between El Progreso and Tela. As we entered a beach-side hotel, our friend warned us not to venture onto the beach alone or far from the hotel, for fear of being assaulted. This was our first afternoon in Tela. The next morning, my son got up very early, at 6 a.m., to view his new surroundings and take some pictures. As he was standing no more than 30 feet from the hotel front, he was attacked and robbed by a young man wielding a machete. My son did not resist, as the youth was armed and, as a tourist, my son did not want any trouble. On advice, we reported the robbery to the local police and we later identified the assailant, who was arrested. Just hours later, the same criminal was on the beach, saw my son, and beat him up badly, evidently as reprisal for turning him in to the authorities. Asking why a known criminal was set free within hours on the same day of his crime, we were told that minors could not be held by police and had to be released. We asked what proof the assailant showed to be allowed freedom from prosecution and we were told it was simply on his word that he was a minor. I have traveled to many countries, lived in Colombia and Mexico -- both notorious for high levels of crime, but nowhere have I seen such indifference to crime as in Honduras. The laws actually protect known criminals from prosecution, under the guise of "human rights" when mistreatment of human rights is not even the issue. This is a matter of justice. In other countries with a more civilized view, minors (if indeed they are proven to be minors, though this punk looked to be in his twenties) are penalized through a system designed for minors, and not simply liberated and encouraged to continue their rampage. We will never visit Honduras again, especially Tela, and would discourage anyone else from coming to what otherwise is a very pretty town. Jerry Whitmire |
The emerging crises of public order By ERLING DUUS CHRISTENSEN When I returned to Honduras a year ago last May, the nation was preoccupied with a crises of the environment. Returning to Honduras last week after an absence of nearly two months, is to find a nation preoccupied with the rise of violent crime, and seething with discontent. There is a wide feeling that things are becoming unglued and that the society teeters on the edge of the abyss. As if to highlight this situation, the nation has just undergone what appears to have been an unsuccessful coup led by discontented military officers. It does look as if President Flores and democracy have won an important victory over a military establishment that is obviously panicked over losing its autocratic hold of the society. However, unless security, tranquility, and equity can be established democratically in the society, and in fairly short order, this triumph will be short-lived, and will be revealed to be essentially hollow. There have been a variety of rumors and reports. What is being said officially is that what has happened is simply that the administration carried out a shake-up of top military personnel, sending some individuals into retirement, demoting others. This created a tense situation, but nothing approaching an emergency. Almost nobody believes this interpretation of events. An interesting and revealing aside to the story involves rumors that Col. Mario "the Tiger" Amaya had flown to Venezuela to seek advice from President Hugo Chavez about how to carry out a coup against a democratically elected government. Amaya denies this, but admits that he would very much like to meet Chavez and hear his account of the road he followed to the assumption of power in Venezuela. Amaya further said he might himself like to become a presidential candidate, and that he would like to lead a "coup against the poverty, misery, and ignorance" within the Honduran society. He further asserted "in this society we have three groups: we have the poor, we have the miserable, and we have the corruptocracy, and I think this situation must be corrected." It comes as no surprise that the Chavez movement in Venezuela is striking chords elsewhere. A few months ago this reporter wrote: "If the political parties do not change and become genuine parties of the people, expect a Honduran Chavez to rise from the rubble. Since Honduras has no wrestlers (as in Jesse Ventura, Reform Party governor of Minnesota), it is likely that, as in Venezuela, the popular hero will come from the military." What we are witnessing in the wake of the collapse of socialist alternatives is an accompanying loss of faith in traditional two party democratic capitalism, for the simple reason that it is increasingly dominated by financial elites, and is not rooted in the will of the people. Democracy is not a politically neutral concept. It is defined as a system of government which locates power in the people, and not in elites. Whenever a populace is denied power, is essentially disenfranchised in favor of elites, a lack of stability is predictable. The current scramble amongst elitist politicians in Honduras, whether liberal or nationalist, to see who will succeed Carlos Flores, can be reassuring to nobody who seriously contemplates the economic and social realities festering in the country. Something tells me that we have not heard the last of "el Tigre."
|
Monday, August 9, 1999 Online Edition 169 |
U.S. Congress snubs SOA, cuts funds by 10% Symbolic victory is seen as
first step to By W. E. GUTMAN WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Sighs of relief and elation greeted the precedent-setting decision by the U.S. House of Representatives to cut U.S. taxpayer funding for the U.S. Army School of the Americas (SOA), a military institution that has been immersed in controversy and marked by scandal since its creation in Panama in 1946. "All these years of going to prison, fasting and protesting," said Father Roy Bourgeois, smiling through his tears. Bourgeois is a decorated Vietnam veteran and Maryknoll priest who vowed to avenge the 1989 murders of six Jesuit priests and two women in El Salvador. "It's been a long, hard struggle." Held during a debate on next year's foreign operations spending bill, the 230-197 vote is a clear setback for the SOA. The school has trained hundreds of officers who went on to commit horrific acts of brutality during a decade of state terrorism, kidnapping, illegal detention, torture and wholesale murder. The SOA has produced some of the worst human rights abusers in Latin American history. Symbolic, though significant, the House action would eliminate only about 10 percent of the $20 million in federal funds earmarked next year for the school. The rest of its funding comes from the Pentagon budget. Relocated in Fort Benning, Georgia in 1984, the SOA has survived four increasingly narrower votes of support in the past six years. Rep. Joe Moakley, D-Massachusetts led the congressional investigation into those 1989 murders and sponsored the amendment on 30 July that led to the most recent House vote. "If we don't stand for human rights in Georgia, how can we possibly promote them elsewhere in the world?" Moakley asked. Rep. Sanford Bishop, D-Georgia, a fierce defender of the school, said that investigations by Congress and the Pentagon over the past decade did not support allegations that the school teaches torture. Independent investigations by human rights organizations and thousands of depositions by witnesses and victims' relatives contradict Rep. Moakley's claims. For it part, the Pentagon insists that the SOA is a "vital instrument" of U.S. strategy in Latin America, that it encourages civilian control of the military and fosters respect for human rights. Opponents in Congress argue that human rights abuses by the school's graduates are continuing even today, and that the institution is an anachronism now that the Cold War is over and most Latin American nations are now led by democratic regimes. "This school is a blight on the image of the United States among the people of Latin America," said Rep. Jim McGovern, D-Massachusetts, a sentiment shared by senior Senators Ted Kennedy, Christopher Dodd and Joseph Lieberman. Said an SOA opponent: "We are determined to garner enough Congressional support to turn a small victory into an unqualified triumph. We are determined to close the school for good." Sources close to the issue caution that the SOA will never be shut down but simply relocated outside of the United States, "probably in Central America, well out of the reach of American scruples." Status quo shaken, military stirred By JORGE FLORES MCCLELLAN TEGUCIGALPA -- If there was no threat of a coup d'etat in Honduras last Friday (July 30), it definitely looked like one. If everything was well between the democratic civilian government of Carlos Flores Facusse and the hierarchy of the military, then, why was the president's helicopter standing by his door with turbines running for three hours? Why was security at the presidential palace increased? And the question lingering in the air, why were all the electronic media on "cadena nacional," blaring martial music and continuous official communiques that were so reminiscent of past governmental power crises? These details might have escaped the cynic, hardened observer, used and abused to hearing national broadcasts for every little thing from presidential decrees to annoying announcements of a raise in teachers salaries, to declaring national vaccination day. But the fact remains that rumors of a military overthrow had been flying since both President Flores and Minister of Defense Edgardo Dumas had announced instability in the military beginning in May up until that week. It sure looks like this was no publicity stunt for the democratic government but a real face-off. The pieces of the puzzle were Vice Minister of Defense Gen. Roberto Lazaruz Lozano and Chief of Joint Staff of the Armed Forces Col. Eugenio Romero Euceda, among other top ranking officers, who decided to take some action behind the government's back, perhaps echoing the sentiments of some sectors of society as an exercise of the old military muscle to see how far they could still go. Less of an aftermath and more of an aftertaste is the unsavory way this so called rotation was handled or mishandled to create the disillusion of a coup d'etat. It racked many a nerve up until the anti-climactic reading of the over-used message that all stations could go back to their normal programming. During those 180 minutes or so of suspense, phrases like "golpe de estado" or "golpe de barraca" were whispered, mostly by the older generation, the younger one not knowing in the flesh what these imply. The whole of Honduran society is still reeling from the shock of this unexpected "blast from the past." But all is well that ends well. The normal democratic procedure for a civilian government to exert constitutional control of the military has been followed to the letter for the first time in too many decades, and the changes have been made in the echelon. The successful coup came from the other hand for a historic change. Apparently, the tables have been turned for good in the face of globalization in the third millennium. As President Flores said in his speech during the command rotation, this is no routine exercise to be downplayed, but a proof that Honduras is controlled by civilians. Still, as it is said in the streets, a military government would have been blockaded and banished by the United States anyway.
SOMETHING MORE ABOUT POOR Dear Editor: In response to my essay "Creating an Unconventional Movement for Change in Honduras," Mr. Albert Leering of Canada noted that he wished I had said "something more" about Honduras' poor. Let me state briefly that the whole point of my piece was to focus on Honduras' poor. While I see the solution to many of the problems in Honduras as being the development of a financially-strong, well-educated, and politically savvy middle class, the middle class I am talking about would supposedly be made up of today's poor. I too am "impressed with how the poor manage to survive" in Honduras. I'd like to see them someday do more than just survive. Marco Caceres
TWO THUMBS UP Dear Editor: Excelente! Two thumbs up! Congratulations to Jorge Flores McClellan [for his interview of former President Callejas]. Jose Enrique Luna
Dear Editor: How much were you paid for that interview [of President Callejas]? It sounded more like a press release than an attempt to have him respond personally to questions about his administration. Are we to believe that the allegations of the "chinazo" are nothing but fabrications of the Reina administration? I must confess that after reading the interview the thought that came to me was that your reporter is either fishing for a position in some future National Party administration or he was afraid of offending Callejas. Andrew Larson EDITOR'S NOTE: Jorge Flores asked to respond to Mr. Larson's letter. "Al buen entendedor, pocas palabras." As stated in the interview, Mr. Callejas said President Reina persecuted him and his officials without presenting any hard evidence. What was I supposed to do? Insist on a futile quest? Gouge him to make him confess and hand over the proof? We thought the questions beforehand and omitted the ones that obviously would produce nothing fit to print. To allow for the continuing witch-hunt by those who feel the need for it, we insisted on printing his e-mail address to which he readily agreed. By the way, we forwarded Mr. Larson's message to him and he faxed us a judicial certification that exonerates several people implicated in said case. His name is not even included in the procedures. |
End of story The successor of the Chief of Joint Staff, Col. Daniel Lopez Carballo, has promised to follow to the letter the contents of the law and Constitution. After a grave discussion about the succession of power, the Armed Forces with President Flores' approval, achieved consolidation in its order and ranks and propitiated a real change in its internal rules and regulations by removing Vice Minister of Defense Gen. Roberto Lazaruz. These regulations have historically been ignored or manipulated to create a kind of permanent state of rebellion until civilian power undermined their command and decision-making rights in matters of state. The problems the Armed Forces face are varied. Two awkward examples are there are too many colonels for the small army and the deterioration of the army can be attributed in part to these colonel's insistence to command even if they are too young, some not being older than 40 years of age. This, we find incompatible with our Armed Forces that need expertise, experience and analytical power. We need a military leader of the caliber of Gen. Collin Powell, a veteran of strategic thought and action, for example, or Gen. Douglas McArthur who took Japan at 65 and stopped communism at the 38th parallel in Korea at 73. We have met and talked with Honduran generals who have graduated from international schools, roaming the streets of Tegucigalpa, retired but still in the prime of their life, looking as if they could give decades more of valuable service to our country. So, the weaknesses of the Armed Forces have not been caused by the intrusion of civilian power in its ranks and files. On the contrary, it is the constant internal purges that weaken the institution which is supposed to be the most disciplined. These in-house cleanings create antagonism due to a cabin fever in which everyone wants to have the power. President Flores has had a hard time resolving internal affairs that for generations have plagued the military hierarchy and has asked publicly that there be no more confrontations or divisions inside the army. A few days ago, a young man, when asked about his future in the army, said that since he was the best man in his group, he would be chief of staff in so many years. What we wanted to hear were his moral principles and virtues as a future officer, and his contributions to the institution and country in return for the high cost of maintaining the army. In short, we want to state clearly that we do not wish the abolishment of the army, but order, real discipline and the execution of the principles for which it was created.
|
Monday, August 2, 1999 Online Edition 168 |
Why tourists stay away Rising crime and violence, that's why By W. E. GUTMAN There's nothing like bad news from afar to spoil a well-earned sabbatical and coax a reporter back into the fray. Take the recent drive-by gangland-style massacre in Copan Ruinas, which claimed five lives and scorched the soul of a quaint and skittish village habituated to intermittent violence and accustomed to looking the other way. Five people. Was it revenge? Were they victims of mistaken identity? Were they felled in a drunken rapture by giddy campesinos celebrating a soccer score? Or were they targeted for assassination in a drug deal gone bad? Speculations abound.
When the smoke lifted, dozens of spent AK-47, 40 mm. and 9mm. caliber shells lay on the ground, silent accessories in a drama that began and ended with lightning speed in the rain after dusk. They offer few clues. Everyone is armed in these parts. Nothing like a community that hurriedly mops up the blood, plugs up the bullet-riddled walls with cement and seals its collective mouth in a terror-driven reflex -- to sharpen fear and blunt one's sense of well-being. Nothing like a craven and slow-witted constabulary -- the murderers got away and the leads grew cold -- to cast grave doubt about the probity of the Copan police and resurrect rumors of criminal collusion. Nothing like a timid, controlled press -- El Tiempo hid the story on page 56; La Prensa buried it on page 75; when contacted by this writer, La Tribuna and El Heraldo declined to talk about the case -- to reflect on a nation's health and moral fiber. Nothing like yet another senseless crime in a country long tormented by lawlessness, traumatized by the greed, arrogance and ineptitude of successive regimes, and disgraced by the ceaseless suffering of its people -- to explain why visitors are scarce and a vigorous and thriving tourist industry is but a distant dream.
**** Corruption is not the only evil that vexes Hondurans. They are also outraged by the arrogance that accompanies it. Groomed to inherit, by political incest, the power, prestige and economic sovereignty forever shared by a handful of dominant families, tomorrow's elite, like yesterday's, will continue to dine together and offer each other jobs and trade favors and influence while asking the nation for time and patience. Time is one asset Honduras does not have. The cost of putting off the reforms the country desperately needs is irreversible economic slippage. The potential for disillusion to turn to violence in Honduras should never be underestimated. This is a country which, it is said, cannot reform, but evolves through revolution. Meanwhile, it remains a violent and dangerous place both for Hondurans and for those in search of El Dorado. EDITOR'S NOTE: The U.S. State Department Travel Advisory for Honduras can be accessed on line at <http://travel.state.gov>.
|
INTOXICATION A famous restaurant in Tegucigalpa was closed this week by health authorities due to the fact that its cheese sauce was contaminated with E. coli bacteria. In what may be a first for the country around 80 people were intoxicated and treated in several capital city hospitals. To date, the medical costs, some of which were very high due to the seriousness of several individual cases, have not been recognized by the owners and to add insult to collective injury, not even an apology has been issued. But the heart of the matter is the supervision and vigilance of food establishments in Honduras. In our opinion, restaurants and other business should be supervised not only by the health ministry but by the Tourism Institute as well. Permits issued to them should be based on high qualifications to people who know the basics in hygiene, correct food preparation and management. There are several institutes in the country that give training in such areas as restaurant control. Besides passing through this training, restaurant owners and managers should attend a follow-up program to monitor their progress continually. This is to insure insure that food-poisoning incidents will not be repeated in the future. In other parts of the world where tourism is a priority and fostered, besides being hygienic restaurants display local delicacies with pride. Also, prices are displayed so that there are no hidden charges or other surprises when she check comes that may cause indigestion. Order and discipline are shown in every detail, clean tablecloths after every meal to presentable waiters and waitresses who can be mistaken for the owners of the place for the care they take in their appearances. There are many such places in our country but this is not due to government policy. There are many nice and clean restaurants because there are many nice and clean owners and managers who respect common rules of decency voluntarily. We call on all restaurateurs to guarantee transparency in their respective establishments. We know that after this unsavory incident many will elevate their standards of quality and ensure better service. But we also call on health authorities to point their microscopes at their own rules and regulations and the Tourism Institute to create a better environment for investment and service. Also, the National Institute of Professional Training (INFOP) should revise their focus o this very important aspect of society. We believe the E. coli bacteria came only to remind us not to let our guard down and it will not prevail. To prove our confidence in the goodwill of all legitimate businesses everywhere, we already talked to the owners of the restaurant in question and promised them we would return once the problem is overcome. One apple will not spoil the whole bunch.
|
|
|||||||